Scoped research reviews
A collection of checked calculations and documented attempts, with evidence and explicit limitations. Specialist review is sought where it can resolve a specific question; it is not claimed for every case.
PROJECT & SUPPORT
Second Derivation checks specific results in published papers and prepares scoped reviews with evidence and, where available, runnable code. A review may also document an incomplete reproduction attempt.
WHY THIS PROJECT
Independent verification takes time: reconstructing assumptions, rebuilding calculations and resolving disagreements. Making that work reusable gives each check value beyond a single paper.
The project grew out of Rodion Popkov’s own cosmology research, which involved re-checking calculations in other papers with AI models. Rodion is an independent developer and product manager in Berlin. There is no team or external reviewer yet; finding specialist reviewers is part of the pilot.
THE RESEARCH PILOT
A collection of checked calculations and documented attempts, with evidence and explicit limitations. Specialist review is sought where it can resolve a specific question; it is not claimed for every case.
The workflow and reusable checking tools documented alongside the cases that motivated them.
Versioned GitHub packages with reports, evidence, and code and data instructions where supplied. Archival DOIs are a future goal, not a claim that these candidates are already archived.
SUPPORT THE PILOT
Budget and timeline are not fixed yet. Support would fund independent specialist review, research software development and computing time. Academic collaboration is also a valuable contribution.
Progress will be assessed through reproducibility, scientific usefulness, false findings and the human effort required. Public methods and released research materials are the intended outputs.
Sponsorship will be disclosed. Scientific conclusions must remain independent of the funder.
Discuss research support